Skip to main content

The death of music writing - Music is Math

Christopher R. Weingarten (@1000TimesYes) - Music Writer, and Village Voice

My job as a rock journalist became obsolete right about the time I joined the industry. Weingarten explains how search engine optimization is dumbing down music writing and no one is thinking critically, magazines hire bloggers who just plug in trending keywords to get as many hits as possible. Because albums are leaked months before they hit shelves consumers can listen to the album and they don't need a music reviewer to tell them what it's like. They can decide if they like it or not, this is good and bad, it's turned the music writing industry into a game of "firsties," no one cares about the quality of the message as long as they get it out first.

This kind of piggy-backs on my discovery that every time I mention Tegan and Sara in my blog readership spikes

"Good writing dies at the hands of search engine optimization," Weingarten said and the crowd applauded. It's really a brilliant lecture, well worth a listen.

Weingarten writes twitter album reviews here.

Fleet Foxes, Tegan and Sarah, Broken Social Scene, Lady Gaga, She and Him, Vampire Weekend, OutKast, Surfer Blood, Flobots, Girl Talk, Iron and Wine, Death Cab for Cutie... you get the picture. 


Emily said…
Makes me sad. Music writing is an age-old art! The process should be respected!
stupid marketing and money-money-chasing.
You are an excellent rock journalist even if it's "on it's way out."
My hope is that there will be a pendulum swing in our lifetime and we'll all get a chance to put down our cell phones and iPods and just experience life...
Anonymous said…
I find it amusing, and I completely concur with the author of this article. I personally have become jaded with the way popular music in general has become less about content and even more about the money. Fret not, if you look hard enough outside the labels you will find those that are my kindred. Working by day and passionately toiling away, composing, experimenting, and tinkering by night.

Many people have really, truly forgotten the spirit of musicianship and being a composer. I could spend every night of my life writing music, not releasing it, not making a penny and be happy about it....or maybe I'm just a recluse, take your pick. Good day and goodbye for now.

Popular posts from this blog

Firefly Portraits: The Crew of Serenity

I've been heard at work making this fun posters featuring the crew of Serenity with memorable quotes.
I've done everyone except Simon, mostly because I haven't found a compelling quote from him yet.
So here's a long graphic of all the posters, perfect for pinning! (hint hint).
Right now you can get $5 off any of these great prints, t-shirts or tote bags in my Society6 shop.
If you like this, don't hesitate to share it amongst your sci-fi loving friends.

Which quote/illustration combo is your favorite?

I Shot First - A Han Solo Halloween

This past Halloween I wanted to do something inherently sexy. Who is sexier than Han Solo? Answer: no one.

I started with pictures of Han. Specifically from "A New Hope."

Here are the elements: Off white, mandarin-collar shirt Black/navy vestDark pants with red stripesBlack boots (I already owned a pair)Belt and holsterBlaster
I started at Thrift Town, where I found a pair of dark slacks, a shirt, and a black suede jacket. I think I spent around $12. I cut the sleeves off the jacket and used red duct tape for the stripes. 
I ordered a toy blaster online, it only comes in white and orange. So I had to spray paint it. I used this tutorial.

If I was going to go further with this costume I'd make a replica of the belt, like this awesome woman did.

Luke really wanted to be Luke this year. His costume was a little more tricky. We bought a karate uniform online, he used a pair of khaki pants he already had and we tried to make the boots out of Ace Bandages, but that didn't w…

Guest Post - Hand-made roll-up panniers by Libby Bowles

It's bike month everyone! Don't forget to check out, and register to win prizes and such. In other exciting news, my amazing friend Libby can do anything! She saw my post about panniers a while back and got it in her head to make a pair of these roll-up brooks brand panniers - and she did. Here's the story:
Hey there Melody,  Remember these (Brooks roll-up panniers)?Well, I was so in love that I decided to make my own. They still need a few finishing touches but I was so excited I just had to show you. 
I'm going to Tandy Leather on Monday to get the studs for the little internal straps and maybe get a set of leather handles to sew on top so I can carry them like a satchel while shopping.  I made the pattern based on the size of a paper grocery bag so they should be big enough for two full bags of groceries! I think they look perfect on my Gazelle, don't you? (Yes, they look amazing).
I wanted to make them a little prettier on the inside so …